Transparency & Standards

Fact-Check Methodology & Editorial Standards

Our core editorial philosophy is simple: India-first in perspective. Evidence-first in judgment. This document explains how claims are selected, researched, audited for bias, and evaluated against primary Indian records.

1. Core Product Identity & Editorial Principles

DimagiNaxalite is an independent Indian investigative and media-literacy platform defending:

  • India’s Constitutional Democracy & Rule of Law: Evaluating governance through democratic institutions, statutory enactments, and judicial decrees rather than partisan dogma.
  • Opposition to Political Violence & Anarchy: Distinguishing legitimate democratic protest from violence, intimidation, terrorism, mob violence, and destruction of public property.
  • Freedom of Expression & Equal Citizenship: Protecting all Indian citizens across religious communities (Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, and others) from targeted misinformation and incitement to hatred.
  • Hindu Civilisational & Cultural Continuity: Providing deep epigraphical, historical, and archaeological scrutiny on claims affecting India's civilisational heritage without historical denialism or false euphoria.

Critical Symmetrical Rule

Evidence determines the verdict. The platform never labels a claim false or true based on whether the speaker is Left-wing, Right-wing, Congress, BJP, Hindu, Muslim, pro-government, or anti-government. If the evidence proves an opposition claim true, it is published as VERIFIED TRUE. If the evidence proves a pro-government claim false, it is published as FALSE.

2. The 5-Tier Evidence Hierarchy

The engine applies an explicit 5-tier evidence hierarchy. Secondary commentary or viral social popularity is never treated as proof of truth.

Tier Category Primary Sources Included Evidentiary Weight
Tier 1 Primary Evidence Gazette of India, Parliament debates (Sansad), Supreme Court & High Court judgments, Election Commission of India, RBI, SEBI, Census, RTI responses, ASI excavation monographs, authenticated master speeches/broadcasts. Decisive & Highest Priority
Tier 2 Institutional Evidence Universities, peer-reviewed scientific journals (BSIP, Lancet, Cambridge), international statutory bodies (UNESCO, WHO), recognized professional institutes. High Priority for Scientific/Historical Claims
Tier 3 Established Journalism On-the-ground reporting, verified chronologies, accredited eyewitness dispatch, investigative reporting by transparent newsrooms. Used for chronology and discovery; distinguished from primary proof.
Tier 4 Secondary Analysis Fact-checking registries, think-tank policy papers, research summaries, encyclopedic references. Used for corroboration; verdicts are not imported blindly.
Tier 5 Social Media Posts X (Twitter), WhatsApp, Telegram, YouTube comments, viral threads. Used exclusively to establish *what was claimed* and *how it spread*. Zero evidentiary weight as proof.

3. The 14-Step Investigative Research Loop

01
Claim Extraction: Parsing verbatim claim, claimant, date, and distribution platform.
02
Claim Type Detection: Classifying as Factual, Statistical, Historical, Legal, Media, or Opinion.
03
Context Analysis: Checking Time, Location, Event, Person, Law, and Denominator baselines.
04
Source Discovery: Executing multi-source search across Indian government portals and court registries.
05
Primary Source Prioritisation: Filtering and ranking Tier 1 primary documents above secondary news reports.
06
Multi-Source Verification: Cross-referencing independent institutional databases for consensus or divergence.
07
Contradictory Evidence Search: Actively querying counter-evidence that could falsify the initial hypothesis.
08
Source Credibility Analysis: Evaluating proximity to event, publication date, conflicts of interest, and methodology.
09
Temporal & Geolocation Audit: Verifying if old footage/images are being recycled to mislead.
10
Fallacy & Rhetoric Check: Flagging cherry-picking, whataboutism, false equivalence, and emotional framing.
11
7-Point Bias Audit: Mandatory internal bias check executed prior to verdict formulation.
12
Evidence Weighting: Synthesising atomic claim statuses into High/Medium/Low confidence levels.
13
Verdict Formulation: Mapping results against the 11-tier standardized verdict taxonomy.
14
Source Transparency Dossier: Generating traceable [S1], [S2] citations and audit trail.

4. The 7-Point Internal Bias Audit

Every fact check undergoes a mandatory internal audit consisting of seven adversarial questions:

A. Identity Test

Would the verdict remain identical if the speaker's political party, religion, or ideological identity were completely anonymized?

B. Direction Test

Would the exact same evidence produce the same verdict if the claim supported the opposite political or ideological faction?

C. Source Test

Are we rejecting evidence because of the publisher's political reputation rather than its primary evidentiary value?

D. Confirmation Test

Did the research loop actively search for primary sources that contradict the preliminary conclusion?

E. Language Test

Is the analysis free of emotionally loaded words, partisan sarcasm, abusive labels, or polemical framing?

F. Omission Test

Did we omit relevant context, statistical denominators, or counter-arguments that weaken our conclusion?

G. Standard Test

Are we applying the exact same threshold of proof to equivalent claims regardless of who made them?

5. Anti-Hallucination Rules & AI Guardrails

The DimagiNaxalite engine treats AI models strictly as research orchestrators. AI is never the final authority.

  • Zero Fabricated Citations: The engine is prohibited from inventing court judgments, gazette numbers, URLs, or quotations.
  • Strict "Unverified" Rule: When primary evidence is unavailable or inconclusive, the engine explicitly outputs UNVERIFIED. It will never guess or manufacture a conclusion.
  • Traceable Source Mapping: Every factual sentence in a dossier must link to a specific numbered source identifier (e.g. [S1]).

6. Corrections and Challenge Policy

Fact-checking is an ongoing evidentiary discipline. When new primary evidence, official gazettes, or court judgments emerge:

  • We never silently edit or erase historical verdicts.
  • A permanent Correction Notice is appended to the top of the dossier explaining what changed, the date of modification, and the new primary evidence.
  • Any researcher or citizen can submit a formal challenge using the "Challenge This Fact Check" modal on any dossier. All submissions with primary links are reviewed by the editorial desk.